The other night there was an interesting conversation in the Twitter-mom-o-verse about feminism and the phenomenon of women beating each other’s brains out about the choice to breastfeed or bottle feed. The conversation quickly devolved into jokes about all the things that are worse for kids than formula (dog food, window cleaner, and poop were all discarded as valid feeding choices) but it got me thinking, and not just thinking about the time my son tasted cat food. Although that was pretty funny. I gathered from the expression on his face that cat food did not taste as good as he hoped it would. Good thing, too, since my cat is on really expensive prescription food and I don’t want to have to buy it more frequently because my kid has started eating it when I’m not looking.
Anyway, I was thinking, which you can see is dangerous due to my penchant for thought tangents, and I was trying to come up with a good definition of feminist. One that transcends the usual feminist touchstone arguments like breast v. bottle, full-reproductive-choice v. limited-reproductive-choice, taking-husband’s name v. not taking husband’s name and all the other made-for-mainstream-media arguments. Because those things aren’t at the heart of feminism. A woman’s position on breastfeeding, or contraception, or working outside the home, are not indicative of her status as a feminist; they are indicative of her individual preferences and circumstances. A feminist can bottle feed. And feminist can have an epidural with impunity. A feminist can take her husband’s name, stay home with her kids until they’re 16, and use the rhythm method as birth control.
What would be anti-feminist is if that say-at-home-mom tells her daughter that her main purpose in life is to serve a husband and children because she was born female and that is the only future women should seek and no other choice is as valid. Or if a working mom told her daughter that staying at home is a curse that no woman should ever endure and she should under no circumstances choose full-time child-rearing because a paid career is the only valid choice.
I’ve always considered myself a feminist because of this single idea: I flatly reject the thesis that my lifepath must be dictated by gender and that I must accept a particular type of treatment based on my gender. I know that there are people out there who still adhere to “because you’re a girl” reasoning, but that is not my problem. I do not accept that line of thinking (unless “because you’re a girl” is preceded by “why do I get my period?”) and I will find ways to avoid, circumvent, and alter situations where someone it trying to use it to limit me.
I do not think that my status as a feminist should be called into question because I got an epidural as soon as the anesthesiologist could make his way to my room. I am not less of a feminist because my husband, son and I all have the same last name. My feminist cred was not heightened by my choice (and ability) to breastfeed for a year. Those are choices I made as an individual, choices that I used my autonomy, education, emotions, and logic to make. Feminism only came into play when I thanked my lucky stars for all the generations of feminists who threw their backs into making sure that I was in a position to make all those choices, unhampered by oppressive gender-role restrictions.
A special shout-out to the feminists who pushed for the great breastfeeding protection laws in place in DC that allow moms who choose to breastfeed to do it anywhere they want without fear of harassment and that guarantee moms who pump a clean, private place to pump at work, time to do so, and a sanitary storage space for expressed milk. You all rock and make the choice to breastfeed a little easier!
See, the deal is, all these choices we make, like breast or bottle, co-sleep or crib, natural birth versus medical model, are, at the end of the day, no more significant to the feminist movement than the color of the shirt we chose to wear when we get dressed that morning. The point is that all of those options are available to us because women got together and said “Hey! I want choices! Hand them over!” and said it loud enough, often enough, and determinedly enough that everyone had to listen and give them their choices. Our job now, our job as feminists, our job as women, is to accept that the consequence of a full range of choices is that some women will make choices we wouldn’t make. And that is fine. It’s good. It’s illustrative of the need for a full range of choices to satisfy the full range of need of humanity.
Our second job is to stay vigilant against those who would limit our choices. Just as I don’t want a man with a regressive view of women to tell me I can’t nurse in a shopping mall, I don’t want a woman with a misguidedly militant view of nursing to tell me that I can’t use formula. Neither viewpoint is constructive. They only serve to make women angry, frustrated, and hurt.
The question we women need to ask each other is not “Why are you doing it that way?” but rather “How can I help you do it better?”. Women assisting each other is the best face of feminism.
“I’ve always considered myself a feminist because of this single idea: I flatly reject the thesis that my lifepath must be dictated by gender and that I must accept a particular type of treatment based on my gender.”
I’ve heard from numerous women who have said that my Twitter discussion really got them thinking about all the bloggers cashing in on the title of being a “feminist” and spewing judgements and hatred all over the internet. I really do think we all need to wake up and really think about what being a feminist means and how it should look in our era.
You = nail.on.head.
Found your site through Tiffany on Twitter.
Wow- you really nailed it. And anyone who tells the other that there way is THE only way or they aren’t a true feminist really just needs to get over themselves.
I’ve bottle fed AND formula fed. I’ve tried for a VBAC AND had two C-sections. I’m glad to have CHOICES in the matter of motherhood and to have the support of true friends.
I love the “how can I help you do it better?” I think that’s the most important question of all. Instead of judging, we can embrace the fact that feminism means we DO have choices and we should support each other in them.
One of my favorite psychology professors used to get all ranty and ravey about gender “differences.” My favorite quote: “The only real sex based differences are in the areas of copulation, lactation, and procreation.”
I’ve always considered myself a feminist because of this single idea: I flatly reject the thesis that my lifepath must be dictated by gender and that I must accept a particular type of treatment based on my gender.
I only breastfed for 4 months, got an epi right away, LOVE staying at home more than working, never co-slept, am FAR left wing, Pro-Choice, took my husband’s last name proudly and none of those things define me as a feminist or not a feminist :).
I do what I want 😉
I think I’m either going to find or start the Masculinist Movement.
I think to society, the definition of “feminist” has changed dramatically. I grew up in the 70s, and a feminist was someone VERY different than today. The book I am currently writing explores how women who were raised under the feminist “doctrine” of that time period have evolved.
U ah my sistah from anotha mutha.
This is the second great post about feminism I’ve read today. Thanks.
It’s by Camille at Archives of Our Lives – she’s my online best friend, she’s pretty awesome. http://www.archiveslives.com/?p=4648
I am a feminist and that means I do not believe my life Is defined by my gender – nor is anyone else’s. People who make breast vs bottle or the way you birth a child ” feminist” issues are misguided. Feminism is about power – having the power to make choices that are not limited by gender. Does that mean I don’t believe in gender difference? No. But my daughter and son should be judged as individuals and given opportunities based on their individual abilities, not because one is a boy and one is a girl.
One thing I do know is that no matter how far we come it almost always seems like we are going to be fighting this fight. People still wonder who killed Jesus , yet so few care about who killed womans rights in all its forms before mans saviour even came along. Keep fighting girls, this is a fight that is thousands of years old and I just hope it wont be thousands of years before we are given the god damned equality we deserve.
I was just looking for this information for a while. After six hours of continuous Googleing, at last I got it in your web site. I wonder what is the lack of Google strategy that don’t rank this type of informative web sites in top of the list. Usually the top websites are full of garbage.
The next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I actually thought youd have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could fix if you werent too busy looking for attention.
Just wish to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity in your post is simply excellent and i could assume you are an expert on this subject. Well with your permission allow me to grab your feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the gratifying work.
Hello very cool site!! Man .. Excellent .. Amazing .. I’ll bookmark your website and take the feeds additionally¡KI’m happy to search out a lot of helpful information here within the submit, we want develop extra techniques in this regard, thank you for sharing. . . . . .
This is a topic that’s close to my heart… Best wishes!
Exactly where are your contact details though?
Excellent weblog here! Also your website rather a lot up fast! What web host are you using? Can I get your associate hyperlink for your host? I want my site loaded up as quickly as yours lol
Great blog! Is your theme custom made or did you
download it from somewhere? A design like yours with
a few simple adjustements would really make my blog shine. Please let me know where you got your theme.
hi!,I really like your writing very so much! share we keep in touch more approximately your article on AOL? I require a specialist on this house to solve my problem. May be that is you! Having a look forward to see you.
We are a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community.
Your website offered us with valuable info to work on.
You’ve done a formidable job and our whole community will
be thankful to you.
Selain itu browser ini akan membuat jaringan menjadi lebih efisien, sehingga
dapat mendukung untuk konektivitas yang lebih kencang ketika pengguna browsing
di internet. – Do not say anything to the media “off-the-record. Jika Anda telah tercatat sebagai anggota dalam forum ini, Anda berhak mendapatkan berbagai macam keuntungan, seperti: Anda dapat menulis thread sesuai yang anda inginkan, Anda dapat mengirim dan menerima private messages dari anggota lain dan sebagainya.