Eclipse: MY Saga Goes On

Excerpt from the Diary of Kelly Taylor:

Brandon Proposed.  Dylan bought me a trip around the world.  Decisions, decisions…


Remember on Beverly Hills 90210 (the original one not the next generation one) when Kelly had Brandon and Dylan competing for her affections and Brandon showed up with an engagement ring while Dylan gave her plane tickets around the world?  And she met them both on the beach after much agonizing over who to go with and she said the famous words “I choose me!” And walked away?  That is EXACTLY like the third Twilight book except that Bella Swan?  Is no Kelly Taylor and doesn’t have the stones to pick herself up and walk away.

This whole book she struggled with “Oh I love Edward!  But I love Jacob!  But I want to be a vampire! But I love Jacob! There’s a vampire trying to kill me! Whatever will I dooooooooo??????” Lord, she’s pathetic.  I mean Kelly had an eating disorder, a coke addiction, got shot in a parking lot, got amnesia, joined a cult, dated Steve Sanders and many, many other tribulations and she came away from it all able to realize that Massive Soul Sucking Co-Dependency was not a healthy lifestyle choice and she walked away from the whole thing.  Walked.  Away.

You hear that, Bella?  You can just walk away from guys who want to own you and use guilt, controlling behavior, witholding of sex, and assault (Hello, Jacob?  Wait ‘til she says yes before kissing her! Or she’ll press charges. Oh wait, no she won’t because her father thinks it’s ok for teen-age boys to force themselves on his daughter and he’s a cop.  Nice.  Very good values. ) to get you to do what they want.   You are a complete person all on your own.

I’m pretty disgusted with both Jacob and Edward in this book.  And Bella’s father.  And really all the male characters who seem to have more than a passing resemblance to Bill from Big Love who tells the women in his life what to do and flips out when they show backbone.  Maybe I’m going to Big Love -land because I know Stephanie Meyer is a Mormon but it’s hard not to see that Bella spends an awful lot of psychic energy trying to please men.  And that is not a lesson we should be impressing on young girls who are already unlikely to report sexual assault and partner abuse. And I really don’t like the way Edward dismisses Bella’s feelings about marriage and makes it a contingency for her getting anything she wants out of the relationship.  You know what that’s called?  Douchebaggery.

It’s possible that I might be taking these books and the message they send too seriously, but it’s hard not to use a parent’s eye when observing cultural phenomena. And my feminist hat never comes off.

One thing I will say is that Stephanie Meyer can really build suspense.  Maybe to excess sometimes.  There’s a LOT of building to major events in these books and it’s good enough that keep turning pages, even as I hum “A little less conversation a little more action” under my breath.  And for once we actually got a vampire fight!  FINALLY! I was all jumping up and down on the sidelines when Edward and the werewolf were going after Victoria and yelling “Rip her up! Tear her up! Alll up! RAWR!”

Then Bella went and capitulated to everything Edward wanted, all while bemoaning what she was doing to Jacob and I got all stabby again.

Next up: Breaking Dawn.  Do I get my happily ever after?

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

10 comments for “Eclipse: MY Saga Goes On

  1. April 13, 2010 at 7:44 am

    LOL! One more book! I am so excited to hear your thoughts on #4.

  2. April 13, 2010 at 9:22 am

    I’m excited to hear what you think about #4 too! Read fast.

    Bella just sucks. If my daughter ever acts that way about two dumb boys, I’m going to have to smack her upside the head a few times.

  3. April 13, 2010 at 1:01 pm

    Best post ever ever ever. Love everything about it. LOVE.

  4. April 13, 2010 at 3:27 pm

    OMG. I love that you shredded this book. I was actually begining to think I might be missing something with the way women are so PASSIONATE about these books.

    I will stick to Bridget Jones, Thankyouverymuch. 😉 Oh – and maybe Lestat.

  5. April 13, 2010 at 10:44 pm

    That is HILARIOUS!

    I’m not a big Twilight fan. I read all the books and I’ve seen the movies that have come out so far but only b/c I wanted to see what the fuss was about. They drag on a bit too much for me, though.

  6. April 14, 2010 at 12:52 am

    Yeah, those books were….they were entertaining but Edward just freaked me out. No way would I want a cold ass man near me.

  7. April 14, 2010 at 3:40 pm

    This post is effing hilarious. Good stuff, mama.

  8. Mae
    April 18, 2010 at 8:26 pm

    My favorite so far. I have a sick (and therefore, normal) relationship with the Twilight books. I love them. And the second my daughter learns to read, I will be locking all of them in a biometric gun safe to keep her the hell away from them. I don’t think it should be legal to read/watch them until you’re over 28 years old. You need enough distance from high school to see them for the super heightened uber drama just… FRAUGHT craziness that they are, and not something to be like, STRIVING for! Because had I read this crap in high school… dude. I don’t even want to think about it.

  9. June 30, 2010 at 9:24 am

    These were hilarious. I barely got through the first book and read about 20 pages of the second before I had to stop. Craptacular writing style, horrible anti-feminist message [I am WAY with you on that, and am thankful my daughter, who read all the books, agrees with me wholeheartedly that Bella is a sucker], and really, really dull. I like snappy patter and smart writing, and these books had neither.

    Your reviews, on the other hand, made for excellent reading.

  10. Brigitte
    February 25, 2011 at 12:43 am

    I refuse to support this garbage by even getting on the list at my library. I have 3 kids, my oldest daughter is a tween & I am so happy she thinks that Twilight is crap. In fact she told me she wants us to rent “Vampires Suck” because it makes fun of those kinds of movies. I’m totally with you on the being against even more drivel that tries to tell both girls & boys that it’s ok for girls & women to be treated like objects or worse. My girls totally love Harry Potter & especially Hermione because she’s a strong female character. The HP books have some bad-ass girls & women!

Comments are closed.